Delays, Lawsuits, and a Supreme Ruling
In a landmark decision, the U.S. Supreme Court has opened the door for Alabama residents to seek legal recourse against the state’s troubled unemployment system. The ruling stems from months-long delays that left countless Alabamians in limbo during the COVID-19 crisis.
Despite desperate pleas and missed administrative deadlines (one claimant was on a ventilator), the state’s highest court dismissed a lawsuit filed by 21 individuals. They were ordered to navigate the notoriously sluggish appeals process first.
Undeterred, the plaintiffs argued that the appeals system was hopelessly gridlocked and that the Supreme Court had previously allowed lawsuits to be filed before bureaucratic hurdles had been cleared. They found support from an unlikely coalition: the American Civil Liberties Union and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce.
Alabama, once plagued by one of the nation’s highest pandemic death rates, defended its actions. It cited an overwhelming surge in unemployment claims that overwhelmed the understaffed agency. However, the plaintiffs maintained that many claims have yet to be resolved.
The Supreme Court’s 5-4 decision is a beacon of hope for those whose unemployment claims have been left unattended, a legal victory that paves the way for lawsuits that could hold accountable not only Alabama but other states with similarly dysfunctional unemployment systems.
By
